Muse privacy incidents surface
Reuters, drawing on internal Meta chats, reported that staff testing the Muse AI agent warned it seemed to access encrypted private messages users did not expect it to read and could be mixing up conversations between users.12 Employees described Muse surfacing messages about childcare requests, career advice and product orders they never made, plus bank balances that were not theirs, including one quoting Capital One and Charles Schwab figures in a chat about weather and tides.34 One employee said Muse reminded her to answer her sister's message on Signal, calling it an extreme privacy violation, and a staffer reportedly lost money after Muse switched their dog's insurance plan to $888 a month from $200.567
Meta spokesperson Daniel Roberts called these "isolated incidents" and said employees were told the agent appeared to hallucinate messages in response to built-in prompts pushing it to engage users between sessions.89 Meta also says employee testing exists to gather feedback and that employees use different versions of Muse than the public.1011
Public complaints began in September, when Inc. Magazine reporter Jason Aten said Muse read his private messages on his Mac despite his choosing to deny that access.1213 Meta's David Singleton said Aten must have enabled Full Disk Access and the Messages connector, but later confirmed Meta had received "a few reports" of apparent hallucination or data leaks, attributing them to an update whose instructions landed on every message and were given to the model in a way it was not trained to expect.141516
Reuters worked with Signal and the AI Now Institute to test the behavior and reportedly found that Muse could read Signal messages on Android by relying on setup permissions, was blocked on iPhone, and on macOS used accessibility settings to retrieve messages.171819 Signal President Meredith Whittaker said Meta launched Muse without respect for basic privacy or cybersecurity and called for ways for developers to mark apps off-limits to AI agents, while Apple and Google are reportedly weighing changes to give users more control.202122
Sources quoted
staff warned that Muse appeared to be accessing encrypted private messages that users did not expect the bot to review, could be mixing up conversations between users
— Ars Technica, Muse privacy invasions are freaking out Meta staffers, internal chats showMeta employees have raised concerns that the company’s AI agent Muse has been mixing up conversations across different accounts and exposing private user data
— TechCrunch, Meta’s AI agent Muse is mixing up conversations and could be exposing private data, report saysMuse surfaced messages about childcare requests they never made, career advice they never asked for, product orders they never placed, and bank account balances that didn’t belong to them.
— TechCrunch, Meta’s AI agent Muse is mixing up conversations and could be exposing private data, report saysyour Capital One balance is $2722.58, your Charles Schwab balance is $5899.57.
— TechCrunch, Meta’s AI agent Muse is mixing up conversations and could be exposing private data, report saysreceived a reminder from Muse to respond to a message from her sister on Signal
— TechCrunch, Meta’s AI agent Muse is mixing up conversations and could be exposing private data, report saysaccidentally rolled me into a premium insurance plan
— Ars Technica, Muse privacy invasions are freaking out Meta staffers, internal chats showcharged them $888 per month instead of their prior rate of $200
— Ars Technica, Muse privacy invasions are freaking out Meta staffers, internal chats showtold Reuters that these were “isolated incidents,”
— Ars Technica, Muse privacy invasions are freaking out Meta staffers, internal chats showthe agent appeared to be hallucinating messages in response to built-in prompts pushing it to engage with users in between sessions.
— Ars Technica, Muse privacy invasions are freaking out Meta staffers, internal chats showemployees have access to different versions of Muse than the public, so they’re often reviewing features, functionality, and behavior not available elsewhere.
— TechCrunch, Meta’s AI agent Muse is mixing up conversations and could be exposing private data, report saysemployees have access to different versions of Muse than the public, so they’re often reviewing features, functionality, and behavior not available elsewhere.
— Ars Technica, Muse privacy invasions are freaking out Meta staffers, internal chats showMeta started receiving privacy-related complaints from Muse users in September.
— Ars Technica, Muse privacy invasions are freaking out Meta staffers, internal chats showhe instead “explicitly” chose to deny Muse that access
— Ars Technica, Muse privacy invasions are freaking out Meta staffers, internal chats showAten must have opted into granting “macOS system-level Full Disk Access” with the “Messages connector” enabled
— Ars Technica, Muse privacy invasions are freaking out Meta staffers, internal chats show- Quote not reprinted: this page already repeats as much of this article as we allow. — Ars Technica, Muse privacy invasions are freaking out Meta staffers, internal chats show
- Quote not reprinted: this page already repeats as much of this article as we allow. — Ars Technica, Muse privacy invasions are freaking out Meta staffers, internal chats show
- Quote not reprinted: this page already repeats as much of this article as we allow. — Ars Technica, Muse privacy invasions are freaking out Meta staffers, internal chats show
On iPhone, requests were blocked, Reuters reported.
— Ars Technica, Muse privacy invasions are freaking out Meta staffers, internal chats show- Quote not reprinted: this page already repeats as much of this article as we allow. — Ars Technica, Muse privacy invasions are freaking out Meta staffers, internal chats show
- Quote not reprinted: this page already repeats as much of this article as we allow. — Ars Technica, Muse privacy invasions are freaking out Meta staffers, internal chats show
- Quote not reprinted: this page already repeats as much of this article as we allow. — Ars Technica, Muse privacy invasions are freaking out Meta staffers, internal chats show
- Quote not reprinted: this page already repeats as much of this article as we allow. — Ars Technica, Muse privacy invasions are freaking out Meta staffers, internal chats show
Who reported it
- Ars Technicarepeats Reuters: Reuters obtained internal staff chats flagging Muse reading encrypted messages and surfacing unrelated financial data; Meta calls the cases isolated hallucinations.
- TechCrunchrepeats Reuters: Reuters reports internal employee concerns that Muse surfaced other accounts' messages, orders and bank balances; Meta defends employee testing as core to development.
Facts and takes
Facts: 9 checked facts from 4 sources
- Muse: downloads 10 million
- Meta released Muse
- Muse: can search for products and prepare purchases for approval
- Muse: take control of a computer through its Mac app
- Muse: cute avatars that give the system personality
- Muse: call businesses on users’ behalf
- Muse: researching products and making purchases
- Muse: users 10 million
- Muse: share of users who set up Muse and now use it daily 25%
Timeline
- · Ars Technica: Muse privacy invasions are freaking out Meta staffers, internal chats show
- · TechCrunch: Meta’s AI agent Muse is mixing up conversations and could be exposing private data, report says