Eastern District of Kentucky denies dismissal in AI facial recognition arrest suit
A federal judge in the Eastern District of Kentucky, S. Chad Meredith, denied a Florence police detective's motion to dismiss a lawsuit over an arrest that allegedly relied solely on AI facial recognition.12 Techdirt says the court held that the Fourth Amendment does not let a detective delegate the probable cause assessment to AI, and that no reasonable detective could conclude otherwise.345
Alain Osorio, who lived in Nebraska, was arrested and extradited to Kentucky after Detective Ryan Kilmer ran a screenshot from bank CCTV footage through the police department's facial recognition program, according to Techdirt.678 He was released on bond the day after his January 24, 2025 arrest and indicted in March 2025, and the charges were later dismissed after he showed he was working in Nebraska when the check was passed.91011 Osorio sued the detective for false arrest and imprisonment, malicious prosecution, and assault and battery, and the detective moved to dismiss, arguing among other things that qualified immunity shielded him.1213
According to Above the Law's account, Meredith found that, at this stage, the allegations that the detective delegated probable cause entirely to AI without independent judgment and made misstatements or omissions in his affidavit were enough to deny dismissal.1415 The court reportedly noted that Osorio's booking photo looks nothing like the suspect in the footage, and that Kilmer's affidavit claimed he used "investigative tools" though he used only one, contrary to Florence police policy that facial recognition alone does not establish probable cause.161718
Techdirt says the detective isn't shielded by qualified immunity, which means the ruling is sure to be appealed, and it describes a settlement as the alternative to making this an appellate case.192021 Commentators praised the ruling: Above the Law's author called it the right, studied way for courts to treat AI and contrasted it with a Texas judge's reaction to lawyers' AI use, while Techdirt's author said it could have implications for predictive policing and AI-written police reports. inference222324
What each sentence rests on
The judge there denied a motion to dismiss by a cop who allegedly relied on AI facial recognition, and only AI, to make an arrest.
— Above the Law, AI In Our Courts: Useful Or A Magic 8 Ball?Judge S. Chad Meredith was presented with the issue of whether AI facial recognition technology alone could support a finding of probable cause and justify issuing a warrant.
— Above the Law, AI In Our Courts: Useful Or A Magic 8 Ball?The Fourth Amendment to the United States Constitution does not allow a detective to delegate to AI the task of assessing probable cause.
— Techdirt, Court Tells Cops That The 4th Amendment Doesn’t Cover AI-Generated ‘Probable Cause’And no reasonable detective in the Defendant’s position could conclude otherwise.
— Techdirt, Court Tells Cops That The 4th Amendment Doesn’t Cover AI-Generated ‘Probable Cause’The Fourth Amendment to the United States Constitution does not allow a detective to delegate to AI the task of assessing probable cause.
— Above the Law, Court Tells Cops That The 4th Amendment Doesn’t Cover AI-Generated ‘Probable Cause’The detective decided to run a screenshot of the suspect’s face (derived from the CCTV footage) through the PD’s facial recognition program.
— Techdirt, Court Tells Cops That The 4th Amendment Doesn’t Cover AI-Generated ‘Probable Cause’Osorio — who lived in Nebraska — was arrested and extradited to Kentucky to face criminal charges.
— Techdirt, Court Tells Cops That The 4th Amendment Doesn’t Cover AI-Generated ‘Probable Cause’Osorio — who lived in Nebraska — was arrested and extradited to Kentucky to face criminal charges.
— Above the Law, Court Tells Cops That The 4th Amendment Doesn’t Cover AI-Generated ‘Probable Cause’He was released on bond the day after his arrest (January 24, 2025). He was then indicted by a grand jury in March 2025
— Techdirt, Court Tells Cops That The 4th Amendment Doesn’t Cover AI-Generated ‘Probable Cause’the state’s attorney’s office dismissed the charges after Osorio provided proof he had been working in Nebraska
— Techdirt, Court Tells Cops That The 4th Amendment Doesn’t Cover AI-Generated ‘Probable Cause’He was released on bond the day after his arrest (January 24, 2025).
— Above the Law, Court Tells Cops That The 4th Amendment Doesn’t Cover AI-Generated ‘Probable Cause’He is asserting claims for false arrest and imprisonment under the Fourth and Fourteenth Amendments of the Constitution and Kentucky law, malicious prosecution, and assault and battery.
— Above the Law, AI In Our Courts: Useful Or A Magic 8 Ball?The cop filed a motion to dismiss, arguing that qualified immunity shielded him from liability, among other things.
— Above the Law, AI In Our Courts: Useful Or A Magic 8 Ball?The facts that the cop (a) delegated the entire task of determining probable cause to AI facial recognition technology without using any independent judgment on his part and (b) made misstatements or omissions in his affidavit
— Above the Law, AI In Our Courts: Useful Or A Magic 8 Ball?were sufficient, at this stage, to support the denial of the motion to dismiss.
— Above the Law, AI In Our Courts: Useful Or A Magic 8 Ball?- Quote not reprinted: this page already repeats as much of this article as we allow. — Above the Law, AI In Our Courts: Useful Or A Magic 8 Ball?
- Quote not reprinted: this page already repeats as much of this article as we allow. — Techdirt, Court Tells Cops That The 4th Amendment Doesn’t Cover AI-Generated ‘Probable Cause’
- Quote not reprinted: this page already repeats as much of this article as we allow. — Above the Law, Court Tells Cops That The 4th Amendment Doesn’t Cover AI-Generated ‘Probable Cause’
The detective isn’t shielded by qualified immunity, which means this is sure to be appealed.
— Techdirt, Court Tells Cops That The 4th Amendment Doesn’t Cover AI-Generated ‘Probable Cause’- Quote not reprinted: this page already repeats as much of this article as we allow. — Techdirt, Court Tells Cops That The 4th Amendment Doesn’t Cover AI-Generated ‘Probable Cause’
The detective isn’t shielded by qualified immunity, which means this is sure to be appealed.
— Above the Law, Court Tells Cops That The 4th Amendment Doesn’t Cover AI-Generated ‘Probable Cause’- Quote not reprinted: this page already repeats as much of this article as we allow. — Above the Law, AI In Our Courts: Useful Or A Magic 8 Ball?
- Quote not reprinted: this page already repeats as much of this article as we allow. — Techdirt, Court Tells Cops That The 4th Amendment Doesn’t Cover AI-Generated ‘Probable Cause’
That’s also the AI that writes reports for police officers
— Techdirt, Court Tells Cops That The 4th Amendment Doesn’t Cover AI-Generated ‘Probable Cause’