Human skill and AI reliance
“Human skill and judgment remain essential, and over-relying on AI erodes them”
15 people · 13 agree · 2 unclear · 21 views · 2026-09-24 to 2026-10-05
Who stands where on the statement above, from their own words. A person's side is shown only where two separate readings of the quote agree; otherwise they are under "Side unclear". This page does not say who is right.
Agree 13 people
- ✓Simon Späti
It still helps to know the fundamentals, either way: for programming and designing a product, and for a good PM who knows what is needed but also understands system and architecture design.
But AI makes this obsolete, or seemingly obsolete. That’s why people starting today, or me as well, if I start today prompting away in a new field, all of a sudden, that knowledge is missing.
Having Taste (with AI) is more important than ever.
- ✓blog.bustikiller.com
Wake up. Be brave. Regain control.
You’re losing value, because what you can deliver, your actual value as an engineer (not an AI shepherd) decreases as your brain becomes complacent and yields control to the AI.
- ✓Benjamin Riley
I suspect many recognize the harm that AI has inflicted on their own cognitive development.
the harm is not from its occasional use, but making it part of our mental diet.
- ✓Benjamin Breen
AI, if used for writing or as a replacement for original thought, surely encourages damaging cognitive offloading.
- ✓discourse.haskell.org
Plan together, but then you code.
- ✓hasufell
I would rather have non-AI users do the code reviews
- ✓Sean Behan
Knowing what you want has always been the hardest part.
- ✓Harry Dry
Big ideas are less about creativity and more about conviction.
- ✓agmai.org
We believe that human understanding of mathematics remains of paramount importance.
- ✓Jeffrey A. Turkstra
this entire situation has, I think and hope, helped our students better understand the detriments of taking shortcuts in learning.
- ✓Lauren Wilford
I’m sympathetic to the reasons people use AI agents,” Wilford says, especially for bureaucratic and administrative tasks. “But anything where there’s value to two humans seeing each other and working something out together, I think we’re not sensitive to what might be lost if we try to skip all of that stuff.
- ✓Ahmad Al-Dahle
every engineer must be able to explain, even if an AI generated the PR, must be able to explain what they built. I think if that fundamental premise remains true, then more junior engineers will learn the craft
- ✓researchers on cognitive delegation
the practices and institutions that keep human cognition active: unaided problem solving, verification, critical discussion, [and] periods of deliberate disengagement”
Side unclear 4 people
- ·blog.bustikiller.com
I don’t think I underperform compared to 2 months ago. If anything, I am now more aware of what I’m doing
- ·Hoyt Emerson
We’ve had to know everything about the product/business from day 1. AI just removes friction for us now.
- ·Ahmad Al-Dahle
whether junior engineers are developing their craft and judgement , given that AI is able to do so much work for them now.
- ·mondobe.com
It sounds like a loss of craft, a loss of control, a loss of creativity.
Week by week
- · 2: Benjamin Riley ✓, researchers on cognitive delegation ✓
- · 9: Simon Späti ✓, Sean Behan ✓, Hoyt Emerson ·, Harry Dry ✓, agmai.org ✓, Jeffrey A. Turkstra ✓, Lauren Wilford ✓, Ahmad Al-Dahle ✓, mondobe.com ·
- · 4: Benjamin Breen ✓, discourse.haskell.org ✓, hasufell ✓, blog.bustikiller.com ✓
Built 2026-11-21 06:50 UTC from the news knowledge
graph by code. Every quote was checked against the source's own words; which side a quote takes is a model's reading,
made twice.